Federal mortgage relief plan will help millions keep homes

by Kristin Nelson, KY3 News

Tools
A Flash player error has occurred, please make sure you have the latest Adobe Flash Player. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Story Updated: Mar 26, 2009

REPUBLIC, Mo. -- You've heard the saying a man's best friend is his dog. For Steve Hogan, his horses are his best friends.

"I'm kind of a homebody. I love to come home and play with my horses," said Hogan.

It's really the only hobby he has. Like a lot of Americans, Hogan works two jobs so he can provide for his kids and pay the bills, including a hefty mortgage.

"It's hard to come up with that payment every month after month and it's close to $1,000 and I'd just like to get it back down to where it was at one time, that I could afford.," Hogan said.

A year ago, Hogan's monthly mortgage was roughly $600. When he divorced, he had to refinance his home.

"I had to pay out some equity, so I ended up with about $400 more in my house payment than what I previously had," said Hogan.

According to his real estate agent, Hogan qualifies for President Barack Obama's modification plan because his loan originated before January of this year.

The president's "Making Home Affordable" plan aims to help people keep their homes in two parts, loan refinance and loan modification. The federal government estimates this plan could help up to nine million Americans fight off foreclosure.

Hogan qualifies for the first part of the plan. He's struggling to make payments and even fell behind a time or two. Also, his monthly mortgage payment is more than 31 percent of his gross monthly income.

"People shouldn't be paying more than a third of their income into any house and this effectively is helping people get down to where they're at a third of their income," said Todd Thomas of Eagle Management & Realty 1.

Hogan will not qualify for the second part of the president's plan to refinance mortgages because he fell behind on his mortgage payments, and owners need to be current. Also, owners cannot owe more than 105 percent of the value of their property.

Credit counselors say the plan will help a lot of people.

"This gives us an opportunity to work with borrowers who we know will become delinquent. It's more proactive than reactive and I think there's going to be a lot of interest in it," said Tonya Collister of Consumer Credit Counseling of Springfield.

For Hogan, the modification plan would lower his payment by a few percentage points, knocking off a couple hundred bucks every month.

"And that's a large amount of money. It really adds up," said Thomas.

"If my interest rate and payment were lower, I'd feel like I'd have that breathing room," said Hogan. "I throw a saddle on this guy and go riding and I forget about, for a little while, that I need 25 more dollars to make the mortgage payment or to pay the light bill," said Hogan.

So until he can get a lower interest rate, Hogan and his horses will ride out these tough times together.

To learn more about the president's mortgage relief plan, Making Home Affordable, click here.

wow says ...

On Friday, Jul 10 at 8:28 PM

Commenter

I know this is old but really amazed at how rude and hurtful people can be and then not even be stand up enough to put a name or user name just Anonymous. Guess some can't Read the story... how many times does it have to be said, he works to pay it he isn't asking you all for money if he qaulifies for a goverment program to help him out then more power to him. I don't even know this guy but at least he working and not asking for handouts.

ralph says ...

On Monday, May 11 at 6:08 PM

Commenter

Heard you had been laid off Steve.just keep plugging away and things will get better.For you people bashing i can see where it would get hard to pay the bills.The financial secretary of the carpenters union does not pay that much,and i dare anyone to try to pay your bills on missouri unemployment and feed your kids.Alot of us union members will go where the work is but Steve is now a single father he cant very well spends weeks away from home working and take care of his kids now can he.

Steve Hogan says ...

On Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:09 PM

Commenter

Joey I don't want a handout just a lower intrest rate. Good For you for leaving your name. Saywhat the horses arn't a hobby they are what I do. They cost me less than $500.00 last year plus kept my sanity. Another anonymous writer has never bought anything he/she could not afford.Have you ever had your child support suddenly stop? Try having an income and it stop. I live within my means.Try to raise children,as I'm sure most of u do, and not b stretched out.

Steve Hogan says ...

On Thursday, Apr 2 at 5:48 PM

Commenter

Fourth,you mister dairy farmer I have never known a dairy farmer that did not receive subsdies on his milk at one time or another. If thats not a handout what is? Fifth the misinformed gutless person that said I was laid off for being a slacker did in fact call the onwer of the Co. a liar. He told me because of the economic down turn he had to lay people off. Come on anonymous get the facts straight,and let us know who you are.

Steve Hogan says ...

On Thursday, Apr 2 at 5:30 PM

Commenter

I would like to respond to the 36 comments on my story by first saying I don't want a handout I just want a lower intrest rate without the high cost of refinancing. Second I am not a heavy drinker as one anonymous responder would suggest. Third the idot who is a member, and worried about should be ashamed for not knowing how thier union works. The members tell the E-Board how their money is spent.If you have a problem come to the meetings,and let your voice be heard.

it happened to me says ...

On Sunday, Mar 29 at 7:42 AM

Commenter

Bankruptcy, divorce, medical bills & job loss, just trying to hold out until I can sell my home to live with my daughter. I'm trying for a loan modification to avoid foreclosure. You never know what the future will bring so unless you know his story don't judge him.

Maeghan says ...

On Saturday, Mar 28 at 11:16 PM

Commenter

I think he should down size his pro's to con's. Do I want horses or a home. Do I want to be in debt or catch up on my bills..... work two jobs and come out behind or work two and have leisure money after the bills? I wouldnt ever keep animals just because I liked to "play" with them and then threaten losing my home. He could sell the horses at the stock barn and easily come away with a house payment!!!

Anonymous says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 24 at 10:53 AM

Commenter

7:15 ...... You obviously dont know steve hogan

Anonymous says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 24 at 7:53 AM

Commenter

should people that smoke not qualify for help also

Anonymous says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 24 at 7:15 AM

Commenter

Mr. Hogan is not behind in his bills he is current he had 40% equity in his home when he went through his divorce and had to refinance to give his wife 1/2 of that he now has 20% equity in his home but a higher interest rate he would like to lower it which he coukd do without the Obama plan through his lender which any lender will do right now without the Obama plan. Steve Hogan is a hard working man that works 2 jobs and takes care of his family and his property and he is a survivor

Fed up says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 24 at 2:00 AM

Commenter

This is really simple people. if you are paying more than 31% of your gross income on your house payment, then you shouldnt have bought that house. you are not entitled to the house you would love to have. if you cant afford it then sell it. the people who bought a house whithin their means are the ones that should get some help. they are the ones who cant refinace due to property values. why should someone behind on their bills get a better interest rate. seems backwards to me.

Strugglin Dairy Farmer says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 11:53 PM

Commenter

You really cant throw out comments like that if you dont have all the facts.For instance,im a Dairy Farmer and milk price dropped really low for about 2 and a half years about 2 years ago,then it came up a little. At the same time feed price went up and has never dropped.Now milk price has dropped and hit rock bottom and I honestly dont see how any Dairy Farmer can survive.We arent living out of our means, the money we used to make is no longer they same.Do we deserve a loan like that ??

Struggling Dairy Farmer says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 11:45 PM

Commenter

You really cant throw comments out there when you dont know all the facts.For instance, im a Dairy Farmer and the milk price dropped for 2 and a half years 2years ago and then it came up a little but at the same time feed price went up and and it has never dropped. And now once again milk price has dropped but it has hit rock bottom, with feed price like it is I dont see how any Dairy Farmer can survive.Do you think we deserve a loan like that or are we idiots who are not living wtihin our means

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 9:02 PM

Commenter

Mr Hogan is a man that works two jobs and he has custody of his children not his wife and has been able to keep his property and keep from going into foreclosure and is current on his mortgage and you still feel like you have to throw negative jabs at him I hope you judge yourself as much as you judge him.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 6:25 PM

Commenter

I am a Democrat and voted for Obama ... I support his programs that are designed to help homeowners avoid foreclosure .... but if Mr. Hogan is a heavy drinker like some of the comments have suggested .... helping him with his mortgage would actually hurt him with his drinking

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 5:58 PM

Commenter

the average "cost of living" raise is 2-3 percent .... our union raise's have been closer to 5 percent for the past several years ...

exunion member says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 5:36 PM

Commenter

Everyone plz get real!!! Stop kicking him while hes down!!! and being a union member I would think you should stand behind you other members a little more!!! "Union" "Unite".. No wonder the union is weaker now than ever!!! everyone is haveing trouble makeing ends meet. every year prices goes up and up!! and how much does your wages goes up!!!

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:49 PM

Commenter

the obama affordable housing plan is for people that are current as well as behind and I think for any person that works 2 jobs no matter what they are or who they are should be respected not put down.

union member says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:39 PM

Commenter

I am extremely angry at this article before he got laid off he made around 24.00 he got laid off for slacking on the job. How is he going to budget the unions money

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:39 PM

Commenter

Mr. Hogan is current on his mortgage he is not behind he stated that sometimes he struggles to pay it and that if he qualifies he would like to look at a loan modification.

member says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:31 PM

Commenter

His second job is a financial secretary of the carpenters union. If he cannot budget his money how will he budget theirs??

anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:30 PM

Commenter

We believe in helping and the bailout, but there are people who need it more than mr. Hogan

union member says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:26 PM

Commenter

His second job is the financial secretary for the local 978.If he cannot budget his money how can he budget ours?? He makes more money than a two income family!

Mo resident says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 4:23 PM

Commenter

When my wife cheated on me and divorced me I lost almost everything. I now live in a very modest home that I bought as a repo and fixed up over years while I worked more than full time and paid $800 a month child support. It has been hard and I have had to sacrifice a lot, but this is America and at the worst time I was rich compared to most of the world. It has been hard enough for me without now having to pay for other folks to have nicer home than I have, no to mention to $2TR debt incured.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 3:46 PM

Commenter

i believe this situation could happen to anybody too .... but most people would downsize to adjust to their new financial circumstances instead of holding their hand out and expecting taxpayers to lay money in it

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 3:37 PM

Commenter

A homeowner that buys a home for his family does not forsee a divorce where he is forced to give up a portion of his equity in a settlement and take on custody of his children and try to work 2 jobs to keep everything stable. I believe it could happen to anyone.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 3:14 PM

Commenter

I wish i could afford a home with acreage and horses, but i cant .... it seems as though Steve Hogan cant either .... Live within your means and that way you wont have to ask for a handout

If it is worth it says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 2:30 PM

Commenter

I think the plan is ok for those people who cannot not make their payments because they have lost their jobs etc... I hope the government goes through every application with a fine tooth comb. I don't think people who are refinancing (more than once) to pay off credit card debt should count as needing a bailout. This comment is not directed at anyone. If you keep getting credit cards and charging them up then I guess the rest of us should do the same so we can get bailed out too. Not to everyone.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 2:05 PM

Commenter

Aparantly some of the comments (both pro and con)are from people who know Mr. Hogan. I do not, but if Mr. Hogan wants a handout, and lets face it, thats what it is, he should be prepared to be scrutinized just like the big coroporations who recived "bailout money". If he is a heavy drinker ... I want to know it, if he was fired for missing to many days, which could have ment the difference in being able to make his payment or not, ... I want to know it before the taxpayers have to bail him out

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 12:29 PM

Commenter

It's nice the government has come up with this plan based on your gross income. Your lender calculates your repayment ability based on your net income. When will the two ever get together to truly assist people.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 11:58 AM

Commenter

I appreciate Steve coming forward and sharing his story it makes me see that there are other people in this situation and that someone is willing to talk in the public about it Thanks Steve

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 10:49 AM

Commenter

I know Todd Thomas and Isabelle Walker and they have done awesome work to help struggling homeowers do workouts with lenders and were able to help them to stay in their home.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 10:13 AM

Commenter

I believe you have the misconception that because he is a unoin carpenter he has guaranteed work, the fact is that construction is down.Steve got laid off from job and had to sit on the bench until another job came opened and was at a lower pay scale but he had to take it because something is bettr than nothing.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 10:01 AM

Commenter

i personaly know this situation. steve did not borrow more than the house was worth. he was able to make the payment even after he was forced to give his wife half of the equity. he has custody of the children not the wife. he was laid off and was forced to take a lower scale pay job he still continues to make the payments on time he is not behind. because of a life changing events he is struggling. he is making sacrifices. this is not a case of greed

Get a life not someone elses says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 9:55 AM

Commenter

All of you are quick to judge. I am sure if we look into your life there are things you have done that are not perfect. He was married and then divorced. That takes money. He works two jobs, and lost an income by divorce(ex-wifes). Oh I am sure you are saying get another job. What happened to family time? You are quick to judge and one day you will be judged to!!!! Hope God treats you like you treat others!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A Union Member says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 9:50 AM

Commenter

You have to be kidding me,A Union Carpenter in this area ofyour country with the wage he is drawing and he cant make it, what about the others who dont even come close to that wage? Its time to re adjust your priorities and start making smart money spending work for you, thanks for dragging the Union trades down with your sob story !!

anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 9:13 AM

Commenter

what is more important, horses or providing for your childrens home? horses or paying your house payment? where your money lies, so lies your heart. i lost my job 4 years ago and have stopped fishing and taking nice vacations. buck up buttercup.

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 8:27 AM

Commenter

Had to borrow more than your house was worth? Now what is wrong with that picture? How about getting back to the point where if you want something, save at least 10% down and then finance the rest! He wouldn't be in this pickle if he had put down 20%.

Joey says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 8:26 AM

Commenter

These people do not deserve help most of them are greedy idiots who tried to scam the system. Why should I subsidize these peoples houses I am sick of this you owe me mentality. These people are the ones that got us into this mess and now they are going to be rewarded. I say bring back debters prison and send them their for a few years to thik about the problems they have caused to the rest of us who live within our means.

Saywhat? says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 7:57 AM

Commenter

You want the taxpayer to subsidize your mortgage so you can continue to throw a saddle on that guy and go for a ride. Think that might be considered a luxury instead of a right? How much is your maintenance fees on your horse riding hobby anyway?

Anonymous says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 7:34 AM

Commenter

I'm all for helping my neighbors, but maybe these people should have lived within their means, I've never bought anything that I couldn't afford, I guess maybe I'm not normal though.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Comments are screened for curse words before they're posted. We reserve the right to remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum. KY3 and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users.

This is not the place to leave a message about a report for someone in the newsroom, including the reporter, editor or news director. If you wish to contact KY3 News, please do so at our Contact Us section.

Please post comments in upper and lower case typing.

Featured Professional

Pool and Spa Construction, Service, Supplies

Springfield Pool and Spa, Inc.



Springfield Pool and Spa is your one stop shop for backyard fun in Springfield! We have been serving satisfied customers since 1987. If you want a backyard show piece pool complete with waterfall and grotto for entertaining, we can build it. If you just want a nice, relaxing soak in the world’s #1 selling portable spa, we can deliver it.

All of our staff members are trained and ready to meet your needs. We build in ground pools, both vinyl-lined and gunite shell construction. Our pools have won multiple industry awards for design and quality. We sell Doughboy above ground pools, the finest above ground pool you can buy. With many designs and sizes to choose from, you can be assured that your pool will be the nicest and longest-lasting in the neighborhood.

Want a hot tub to go with that pool? You won’t find better than Hot Springs portable spas. Built for energy efficiency first, these spas are also the latest in contemporary style. Hot Springs spas carry a full 5 year warranty, and since 1987 have been serviced by our capable crews at Springfield Pool and Spa.

No calling a 1-800 number to find a technician or worrying that the warehouse you purchase from might not be in the same business next year. Springfield Pool and Spa also provides pool service, weekly pool or spa maintenance, pool liner replacements, and much more. We want to be the folks you trust for any pool or spa need.