Story Published:
Nov 20, 2007 at 6:40 PM CDT
Story Updated:
Nov 20, 2007 at 6:40 PM CDT
SPRINGFIELD -- Here’s some
important information as holiday cooking is about to kick into high gear.
Along with the cooking, there will be fruit baskets that will arrive
soon.
You might wonder the best way
to make sure your produce is as clean as it can be. Armed
with some apples, we turned to a high school science club to find the most
effective way to "wash up" before digging in.
A scientific experiment is what
we wanted -- a way to settle once and for all how to get our fruits and veggies
the cleanest that they can be. So
we took some apples to a classroom, and members of Central High's School Science
Club agreed to accept our mission and test four different ways of cleaning
produce.
They used four ways of cleaning
at four different stations.
Method 1, a favorite with a lot
of these young scientists, is the simple rubdown: no muss, no fuss, just a towel
in this case. In real life
sometimes, it’s just a swipe across a t-shirt.
Method 2 is the shakedown: no
towel here, just running water and a few shakes.
Method 3 involves some serious
soap and water; the method you might expect to really clean up in this
competition.
Method 4 is a vinegar bath, a
little less sudsy but with an unmistakable bouquet all its own.
Each apple was swabbed with a
cotton swab before cleaning for comparison's sake, then both before and after
samples were swabbed onto appropriately labeled petri dishes and stored in an
incubator for three days.
During the experiment, Rhyan
Friesen, our science teacher and lead investigator, tried to dispel our fear of
bacteria in general.
"Most of these bacteria we
could eat, bodies would digest, wouldn't be a problem to us.
But, if there's any E. coli on there or salmonella, you might get sick. But
most bacteria is harmless; the body just digests it,” said Friesen.
That makes us feel a little
better. Still, whatever gets rid of
any potential E. coli or salmonella is what we need to know, and what we were
looking for in these petri dishes.
"You put it under here and
you count the percentage coverage of the bacteria and that gives you a good idea
of how many colonies you have,” said Friesen.
There were plenty of colonies
to be counted.
"The towel one is not
clean at all. It’s got almost 90-
to 100-percent coverage, so don't wipe your apples with towels, people,” said
Friesen.
Not surprisingly, the dry
wipe-down was the least effective method of cleaning in this experiment.
Soap and water didn't do as well as the vinegar bath but, in these kids'
experiment, just plain old running water, shaken, not dried, actually produced
the cleanest results.
"Water actually gathers up
the bacteria and gets if off of the fruit better than the dry sample would,”
said Friesen.
When shaken off, there's no
bacteria added from a towel drying. It
was a lesson that just might change the way these kids at least eat their next
apple.
"I'll probably use water.
Those were the cleanest results,” said one student.
When Consumer Reports
performed a similar test, investigators got a similar result.
Running water worked well, although a very diluted solution of dish
detergent did get rid of a little more bacteria along with the wax.
The bottom line is that running
water, soap and water, or vinegar all work.
You might save yourself a trip to the emergency room by taking a little
extra time to thoroughly wash your fruits and veggies.